Question : DILAPIDATED CONDITION OF MACHINES



(a) the details of machines and other parts purchased by Coal India Limited (CIL) and its subsidiary companies during the last three years alongwith the funds spent thereon, company-wise and State-wise and the details of production increased as a result thereof;

(b) whether most of these equipments are either lying non-functional or are in poor condition;

(c) if so, the details thereof and the reasons therefor alongwith the loss incurred to the various subsidiary companies as a result thereof, company-wise and the action taken by the Government in this regard;

(d) whether procurement of machines and other parts are decreasing in various subsidiaries of CIL;

(e) if so, the details thereof and the reasons therefor;

(f) the norms for procurement, the availability and the use of machine vis-a vis the said norms; and

(g) the steps taken/proposed to be taken by the Government for procurement and use of the machines according to said norms?

Answer given by the minister



MINISTER OF THE STATE IN THE MINISTRY OF COAL (SHRI PRATIK PRAKASHBAPU PATIL)

(a) & (b): As reported by Coal India Ltd. (CIL), subsidiary-wise details of major Heavy Earth Moving Machinery (HEMM) /Under Ground Mining Machinery (UGMM) purchased/commissioned during the last three years are given below:


(i) ECL (West Bengal/Jharkhand)

Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 6 3 7 16 Dumper 30 15 10 55 Dozer 17 1 9 27 Drill 2 - - 2 SDL 31 38 26 95 LHD - - 16 16
Total 86 57 68 211

(ii) BCCL (Jharkhand)
Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 8 3 16 27 Dumper 60 - 38 98 Dozer 16 14 5 35 Drill 7 - 8 15
Total 91 17 67 175

(iii) CCL (Jharkhand)
Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 7 15 5 27 Dumper 97 71 13 181 Dozer 23 14 14 51 Drill 11 - - 11
Total 138 100 32 270


(iv) SECL (Chhattisgarh/Madhya Pradesh)

Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 6 7 8 21 Dumper 110 49 20 179 Dozer 16 15 - 31 Drill 21 1 8 30 SDL 18 36 18 72 LHD 24 95 - 119 UDM 41 7 48
Total 195 244 61 500

SECL has also purchased Continuous miner package in 2010 for an amount of Rs. 39.78 crores (FOB Price) for their Sheetaldhara-Kurja UG min. The machine has been deployed in Madhya Pradesh. The machine has produced nearly 80,000 tonnes of coal, till June’11.


(v) WCL (Maharashtra)

Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 5 16 9 30 Dumper 57 77 18 152 Dozer 17 1 25 43 Drill 8 - - 8 SDL 14 20 20 54 LHD 12 10 27 49 UDM 8 - 21 29
Total 121 124 120 365


(vi) NCL (Uttar Pradesh/ Madhya Pradesh)

Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Draglines - 2 2 4 Shovel 1 7 9 17 Dumper 14 84 23 121 Dozer 18 4 11 33 Drill 6 7 10 23
Total 39 104 55 198

(vii) MCL (Orissa)
Equipment 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 Total
Shovel 9 30 12 51 Dumper 11 44 131 186 Dozer 20 5 8 33 Drill - - 22 22 LHD - - 12 12 UDM - - 12 12 SDL - - 19 19
Total 40 79 216 335

G. Total 710 725 619 2054

(i, ii, iii, iv, v, vi, & vii)


None of the above mentioned equipments are lying non functional or are in poor condition.

The value of equipment and spare parts purchased by CIL subsidiary companies during the last three years are given below:-

Subsidiary	2008-2009	2009-2010	2010-2011
Company

Value in Rs. Crores Value in Rs. Crores Value in Rs. Crores
Equipment Spare Parts Equipment Spare Parts Equipment Spare Parts

ECL 101.88 252.96# 45.87 275.99# 54.43 293.82# BCCL 98.38 40.21 79.74 23.62 323.54 15.43 CCL 187.36 186.64 185.31 186.66 104.89 193.18 WCL 198.44 355.74 163.76 331.03 170.56 354.57 SECL 191.74 86.23 117.90 155.50 202.24 56.39 NCL 85.94 473.41 641.67 446.81 459.02 452.84 MCL 20.95 150.96 421.16 27.78 236.10 30.21
ECL# => Value of stores and spares purchased by ECL.

The raw coal production in Million tonnes of CIL \during the last four years are as under:
Company 2010-11 2009-10 2008-09 2007-08
ECL 30.804 30.06 28.13 24.06 BCCL 29.004 27.51 25.51 25.22 CCL 47.520 47.08 43.24 44.15 NCL 66.253 67.67 63.65 59.62 WCL 43.654 45.74 44.70 43.51 SECL 112.705 108.01 101.15 93.79 MCL 100.280 104.08 96.34 88.01 NEC 1.100 1.11 1.01 1.10 CIL 431.320 431.26 403.73 379.46


(c): Not applicable in view of the reply given in part (a) above.

(d) & (e): The procurement of equipment depends on the need for new equipments as per the project taken up and the replacement cycle of the existing equipments in different mines/projects. The trend can be seen from the tables above that the equipment purchased in CIL shows a mixed trend.

(f) & (G): Equipment are procured by CIL either as per provision of the Project Report or against surveyed off equipment as replacement. Spares are also procured by CIL as per the projected requirement. The percentage availability and utilization of the major Heavy Earth Moving Machines during the last three years i.e. 2008-09, 2009-10 and 2010-11 vis-à-vis CMPDIL norms is given below:

Percentage Availability vis-à-vis CMPDIL norms:

M/c	CMPDIL	Year	ECL	BCCL	CCL	NCL	WCL	SECL	MCL	Norms
Shovel 80 2010-11 78.2 76.6 80.7 77.3 82.7 86.0 79.8 2009-10 77.5 80.1 84.5 70.4 87.5 86.0 85.9 2008-09 77.0 84.1 90.2 67.8 81.5 85.0 91.5
Dumper 67 2010-11 75.2 73.5 71.0 74.2 78.2 68.0 83.6 2009-10 78.9 80.7 80.8 71.5 85.2 72.0 81.1 2008-09 80.1 84.4 80.2 71.5 86.9 78.0 92.0
Dozer 70 2010-11 81.7 73.2 73.3 81.0 81.8 77.0 78.2 2009-10 81.2 81.4 79.7 83.8 80.7 84.0 80.6 2008-09 86.0 85.9 87.3 86.5 85.4 92.0 87.6
Drill 78 2010-11 78.7 73.0 88.3 90.1 87.2 86.0 85.9 2009-10 83.1 73.4 91.2 88.5 93.3 92.0 - 2008-09 87.1 84.4 86.3 80.7 91.7 93.0 -

Percentage Utilization vis-à-vis CMPDIL norms:

M/c CMPDIL Year ECL BCCL CCL NCL WCL SECL MCL Norms
Shovel 58 2010-11 41.1 52.6 46.8 50.0 56.4 58.0 40.5 2009-10 44.7 56.6 53.3 51.0 61.4 62.0 48.5 2008-09 43.0 57.2 49.7 38.0 62.3 48.0 56.8
Dumper 50 2010-11 49.6 46.0 43.2 49.5 53.5 38.0 34.7 2009-10 49.8 47.5 49.3 44.5 57.9 44.0 39.8 2008-09 54.5 52.5 48.1 45.2 58.9 50.0 42.1
Dozer 45 2010-11 38.1 41.7 35.0 34.1 49.8 39.0 42.3 2009-10 43.0 45.5 43.7 33.7 50.9 40.0 48.1 2008-09 50.4 45.1 50.6 37.1 55.6 44.0 51.3
Drill 40 2010-11 40.4 29.6 45.1 22.0 33.7 31.0 40.1 2009-10 40.8 26.8 43.5 23.2 32.2 44.0 - 2008-09 42.1 23.0 37.7 17.2 35.3 39.0 -


The utilization of the equipment is getting adversely affected for various reasons like non-availability of land due to forest or inhabitation, Law & order problem, difficult geo-mining conditions, fire in working coal seams, excessive rainfall, MCC bandhs (in CCL) etc. However, following steps have been taken for improvement of availability and utilization of equipment:

# Effective implementation of Condition Based Monitoring of HEMM.

# Improvement of Reliability of HEMM by planned maintenance & repair.

# Introduction of MARC (Maintenance and Repair Contract) with Original Equipment Manufacturer. All HEMM of high capacity are covered under MARC.

# Streamlining policy for procurement of spare parts for ensuring timely availability of spares to reduce downtime of equipment. Entering into Depot Agreement with various OEMs.

# Skill up-gradation of technical crew by imparting training on Simulators. Tenders floated for procurement of simulators in most of the subsidiaries.

# Introduction of higher capacity equipments and standardizing their capacity.

# Introduction of GPS based OITDS for tracking and monitoring of the movement of individual equipment for its better utilization.

# Introduction of Mechanized Drilling Machines for improving coal availability in mines where SDL and LHD are deployed.